DETERMINING AND DETERRING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
Sunday, February 28th, 2016More than 20 years ago, before domestic violence became a popular, politically correct issue, I learned a lot about it because my wife was a volunteer worker for a New Jersey organization called Alternatives to Domestic Violence. This was long before professional sports leagues woke up and recognized and acknowledged the threat posed by domestic violence.
Aroldis Chapman, Yasiel Puig and Jose Reyes have learned about domestic violence because they have been accused of committing it and face the prospect of being the first players suspended under Major League Baseball’s strengthened policy against domestic violence
Reyes, the Colorado Rockies’ shortstop, has already encountered discipline for violating the policy. Last week Commissioner Rob Manfred placed Reyes on paid administrative leave – in other words, he suspended him with pay – pending completion of criminal proceedings in Hawaii, where Reyes allegedly grabbed his wife by the throat and shoved her against a glass door in their hotel room.
The news release from the commissioner’s office, though, seems to be at odds with its announcement of the joint program last August. That release said the commissioner may place a player accused of domestic violence “on paid Administrative Leave for up to seven days while the allegations are investigated.” The seventh day is Monday, and it’s highly unlikely criminal proceedings will be completed by then.
I discovered the conflicting statements late Saturday night when representatives of the commissioner’s office were not available. (UPDATE: On Sunday, after this column was posted, a spokesman for the commissioner’s office said Reyes was suspended under a different provision, which permits that type of suspension.)
Onto the other accused players then.
Puig, the Los Angeles Dodgers’ right fielder, allegedly pushed his sister in a Miami bar before he got into a fight with the bar’s bouncer. Police said no charges had been filed and they considered the case closed.
Law enforcement authorities in Davie, Fla., said they have completed their investigation of Chapman’s alleged abuse of his girlfriend without filing charges because, they said, they lacked evidence.
Chapman allegedly choked his girlfriend, shoved her against a wall and fired eight shots from a pistol in his garage. That’s one version of the incident.
Another, related by a baseball official, says Chapman, who has been designated as the New York Yankees’ closer, says Chapman was on the telephone and his girlfriend, or quasi-wife, thought he was talking to another girlfriend and grabs the phone. He grabs it back, and she falls to the ground.
Chapman, the tale continues, breaks a window in his car and gets a gun from inside the car. The woman, thinking the gun is upstairs, runs upstairs to get it and calls 911. The upshot of the story, whatever version is true? Everybody recants, a typical outcome of a domestic violence case.
Another outcome: The abuser kills the woman he has abused. Sometimes he kills others. In an episode in Kansas last week, a man allegedly fatally shot three people and wounded 14 others, 10 critically, after he had reportedly been served with a protective order.
None of the baseball cases has produced fatalities. There has been alleged contact, though, and to MLB, none of the three cases is closed and will not be until its investigations are concluded. Then Manfred will decide if disciplinary action is warranted. Under the enhanced program the union agreed to last August, Manfred has sole discretion to determine discipline. The union can challenge disciplinary action through the grievance procedure.
The union’s executive director, though, spoke positively of the policy.
“Generally speaking we had a policy in place,” Tony Clark said in a telephone interview Friday. “But we realized in the climate we were in and the challenges presenting themselves on that topic it made sense to revisit the policy we had.
“We realized that the rule we had wasn’t as comprehensive as it should have been. It had less to do with penalties and acknowledging difficulties that exist in that area and the atmosphere we were in. The discussion on domestic violence had moved more to the forefront. Some of us became more aware of the issue and challenges that existed.”
I was unable to get Manfred’s view on domestic violence or the new policy because he did not respond to a request for an interview. He had Pat Courtney, his chief communications officer, call me to ask why I wanted to talk to him and I told Courtney, but I never heard from either one.
To be candid, I didn’t expect Manfred to take or return my call because he hasn’t returned any calls since I criticized his questionable efforts on minority hiring. He thinks he’s doing a great job in that area; I think he has done a poor, ineffectual job, worse than his predecessor, who in his last years in office slipped into a slump and never recovered from it.
But this column’s subject is domestic violence, not minority hiring, and it exists in Major League Baseball, though seemingly without the prevalence found in the National Football League. The NFL’s experience with domestic violence, in fact, prompted MLB and its union to act more promptly than they otherwise might have.
Clark cited the NFL experience as a motivating factor in baseball’s action. “The NFL was one,” he said. “There were others in the other leagues.”
No domestic violence case has been as prominent or as outrageous as the Ray Rice fiasco in 2014. Commissioner Roger Goodell was responsible for turning it into a fiasco, and Manfred, you can be sure, won’t bumble his way into that circumstance.
Goodell initially suspended Rice, the Baltimore running back, for two games. Then a video emerged showing Rice dragging his unconscious fiancé out of a hotel elevator by her hair. Claiming – falsely as it turned out – that the league hadn’t seen the video before he suspended Rice, Goodell then suspended Rice indefinitely. A judge subsequently overturned the indefinite suspension and Rice was reinstated.
And who applauded the judge’s decision the loudest? Janay Rice, the domestic violence victim herself and now Rice’s wife. One is tempted to exclaim, “Ya gotta be kidding.” But my wife saw it repeatedly those many years ago.
“It feels unbelievable,” Janay Rice told ESPN upon learning the judge’s decision. “It’s a relief. We’ve been telling the same story for months and we always had faith that we’d done the right thing. Everyone deserves a second chance. We’re excited about what the future will bring.”
The future, though, has brought Rice nothing. No one signed him last season, and he sat it out. He remains unemployed.
“Certainly you can see a pattern of aggression with domestic violence throughout the sports world, in colleges as well as professional leagues,” David Cohen, director of Alternatives to Domestic Violence in Bergen County, N.J.,” said in a telephone interview last week. “It’s very hard to turn it on and off if you’re encouraged to be aggressive. You step off the field and you’re expected to turn it off. It doesn’t always work that way.”
Cohen was by no means excusing athletes who batter their wives or girlfriends or abuse their children. He was explaining why it can happen. He also explained why battered victims recant their stories of violence or refuse to testify against their abusers.
Recalling my wife’s stories about battered women’s reluctance to take steps to protect themselves, I asked Cohen why.
“That’s really very much a part of the domestic violence process,” he said. “It is the most commonly asked question: Why does the victim stay? The better question is why is the abuser abusing?”
There are all kinds of reasons for victims staying in an abusive environment:
Fear: “Nothing will keep people in place than fear. The victim would reach out to law enforcement, but as bad as that might be, nobody knows the abuser better than his victim. The procedure with a court case, getting a restraining order, could be dangerous.”
In other words, like the Kansas killer, abusers don’t react well to restraining orders, which could inflame a situation.
Financial: “I should leave this guy for safety reasons but he pays the bills.
Children are involved. If a woman doesn’t leave the husband we don’t bring in the police.”
Testifying: “It’s similar to being a witness to a mob incident. They don’t want to testify. It goes back to that bottom line: Domestic violence is power and control.”
While victims of domestic violence are reluctant to seek their abusers’ arrest, Cohen said, New Jersey has made it easier for them, passing a mandatory arrest statute. “There’s an automatic arrest,” Cohen said. “If police show up at a home and there’s evidence of injury, someone gets arrested. It takes the onus off the victim.”
A victim can seek a temporary restraining order, but as Cohen said, “Nothing is automatic. Police might encourage the victim to get a TRO, but the act of getting it amps up the situation. At the end of the day a TRO is a piece of paper. It is not armor, it’s not a bullet-proof vest. When someone leaves the house” – when he is forced to leave – “the abuser sees he has now lost all means of control.
“We educate victims about a TRO, but we never tell a victim what to do. It is completely her call. She knows what is likely to ensue if she takes that step. No one knows an abuser better than a victim, but some guys don’t want any part of jail.”
As Cohen said, a restraining order is only a piece of paper. My wife recalled an ADV client who had a TRO against a husband or boyfriend, and he beat her to death with a baseball bat.
“In Bergen County alone the past two or three years,” Cohen said, “we’ve had as many as 10 domestic violence homicides. In October an ex-New Jersey cop killed his girlfriend with a Rambo knife. At Christmas time a man killed his wife and child execution-style with a bullet in the back of the head. Some of these guys who commit horrific acts of violence are college and pro football players.”
Chapman, Reyes and Puig have not reached that level of abuse. It hasn’t even been determined if they are guilty of domestic violence.
Yet it’s possible that they could be cleared of domestic violence – Chapman and Puig already have been – and Manfred could still hand down disciplinary decisions. I suspect that is likely to happen so the commissioner can establish a precedent for future cases.
If any of that developed, the union could file a grievance on the player’s behalf and have the impartial arbitrator decide the case or cases.
YANKS WELCOME A-ROD, LOOK TO LINK HIM WITH BABE
The cliché is widely used in baseball: what a difference a year makes. With Alex Rodriguez and the New York Yankees, though, we need to paraphrase it: what a difference 33 home runs and 86 runs batted in make.
When Rodriguez reported for spring training last year following his season-long suspension, the Yankees treated him like an unwashed outcast. They talked as if he might not even make the team.
No one frankly gave him much of a chance to win a starting job, let alone have a productive season. But he fooled them all. And without Rodriguez’s production, the Yankees would not have reached the post-season.
Rodriguez reported for spring training last week, and his reception was 180 degrees different. The Yankees’ view of his contract is different, too.
When he hit his 660th home run last season, tying Willie Mays’ career total, A-Rod, under terms of his contract, was supposed to receive a $6 million marketing bonus. The Yankees, though, refused to pay it, saying Rodriguez’s PED suspension wiped out any realistic marketing opportunity.
The two sides wound up negotiating a settlement.
With Babe Ruth’s total of 714 next on A-Rod’s bonus list, the Yankees plan to pay the $6 million bonus if Rodriguez reaches it. With 687, he needs 27. This time the Yankees will be rooting for him to get the bonus because they expect to make a lot of marketing money linking Rodriguez and Ruth.

He beefed up the starting rotation, signing Jordan Zimmerman (5 years, $110 million) and Mike Pelfrey (2 years, $16 million).
The award, which I created in 2010, goes to the pitcher I decide was the worst of the season. I’ve thought about forming a panel to select the winner, but if I do that, I might be inviting proponents of WAR and other initials into the process.


Baseball has never had to use Latin because the World Series is played in the same calendar year as the season. If, however, numbered designations had been necessary, which World Series was World Series 50? The Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Yankees played it in 1953.