BLACKS, LATINOS NEED TO PROTEST AGAINST MANFRED
Sunday, September 25th, 2016At around the same time Adam Jones was recently gaining baseball-wide notoriety by saying baseball was “a white man’s game,” the Toronto Blue Jays hired an executive and demonstrated once again that baseball is a white man’s game.
In naming Ben Cherington their vice president for baseball operation, the Blue Jays did what all of the other Major League Baseball teams do. They hire white guys as managers and front-office executives. Blacks, Latinos and women need not apply.
The last time I wrote about diversity hiring in baseball, a reader questioned my omission of Kim Ng as a general manager candidate, and he was right so I mention her upfront this time.
However, not that I doubt Ng’s credentials or her ability – she has been assistant general manager of the Yankees and Dodgers and currently is an executive in the commissioner’s office – but I am realistic and certain that no owner will hire a woman to be his team’s general manager. Owners can’t even put aside their prejudices to hire a black man or a Latino.
But this column stems more from the recent eruption of the controversy over protests by black players that were triggered by Colin Kaepernick of the San Francisco 49ers and quickly inflamed by Jones, the center fielder of the Baltimore Orioles.
I have no problem with player protests as long as they are civil and peaceful. If players don’t want to stand for the National Anthem, that is their prerogative. I don’t even understand why the National Anthem is played before sports events. It is not played before Broadway shows or concerts or movies. It is an unnecessary holdover from the patriotic days of World War II.
The attacks of 9/11 intensified baseball’s need for patriotism. Already playing the National Anthem, teams were ordered to play “God Bless America.” That act made Kate Smith the comeback singer of the year.
But the self-proclaimed Mr. USA Patriot himself, George Steinbrenner, went further. Most teams shelved their Kate Smith recordings after a suitable period, bringing it out on holidays and maybe Sundays. The Yankees play it before every game, and the public address announcer asks fans to stand for it.
There is no reason to stand, and there is no Congressional act that requires it. When I have attended games, I have not stood for Kate’s biggest hit.
Baseball players are not rebels. Black baseball players especially are not rebels. There are too few of them to feel they could gain support from their fellow backs. Besides which, they make too much money to be rebels. Jean Val Jean didn’t make $4 million or more a year.
Baseball doesn’t need player protests. Baseball needs a commissioner who will do for minority candidates for the jobs of managers and general manager what he did for David Stearns. Commissioner Rob Manfred “pushed” the Brewers to hire Stearns last winter as general manager.
A baseball official provided that description to me, and I have written it often enough that Manfred has had ample opportunity to dispute it if he disagreed with the characterization, but neither he nor his aide have denied it.
The point is if Manfred could go to bat for Stearns, who worked in his office when he headed the labor division of the commissioner’s office, why can’t he use his big bat for minorities? Bud Selig used to say he couldn’t tell teams whom to hire, but Manfred has made a reasonable facsimile of that idea.
Manfred has talked a better job on minority hiring than he has performed. He has created a pipeline program through which members of minorities are supposed to be able to advance into major league front office positions. However, no role models seem to exist as inspiration for younger employees.
In Manfred’s 20 months as commissioner, clubs have hired or promoted 19 high-ranking executives. Eighteen of the 19 are white males. The lone minority is Al Avila, the Tigers’ general manager.
Has Manfred intervened in any hirings besides the Stearns appointment? I have no personal knowledge of anything, but I would guess not. He certainly hasn’t exerted his influence on behalf of a minority candidate. We know that because none has been hired.
When Manfred demonstrates he is serious about advancing the cause of minorities, I will believe him when he says he is serious. But he has offered no such demonstration.
I have cited the case of De Jon Watson, a black executive with the Arizona Diamondbacks. Among independents and office holders, Watson is considered the No. 1 candidate for a general manager vacancy. However, during Manfred’s tenure, clubs have named 15 general managers and presidents of baseball operations, and Watson wasn’t interviewed for any of the positions.
I suspect Watson has been bypassed because clubs didn’t want to have to explain why they didn’t hire him if they interviewed him.
Watson’s case, however, has become more complex, The Diamondbacks recently decided not to exercise the option in Watson’ s contract , meaning he would no longer be their senior vice president for baseball operations.
This by no means was a matter of merit. It was money and very likely a message to Tony La Russa, the chief baseball officer.
The Diamondbacks hired La Russa two years ago. He had been a highly successful manager but had no front-office experience. La Russa, in turn, hired Dave Stewart, his longtime pitcher and close friend, as general manager, and Watson.
The Diamondbacks enjoyed a 15 -win improvement in La Russa’s first year but have regressed this season and with a week to go were just about back where they were when a La Russa was hired.
This is only my speculation, but I don’t believe La Russa was responsible for Watson’s departure. La Russa spoke so highly of Watson that he wanted to call other clubs that were still seeking a general manager and recommend Watson.
Ultimately La Russa decided that step would have been inappropriate and kept Watson for his own. Now Watson will be moving on.
“I had communicated with De Jon last week about a new hire he was considering,” a Watson friend wrote to me in an email. At no time did he mention he was leaving the DBacks. Then the story broke 2 days later he was out. Very strange.”
As for minority hiring, Watson’s friend wrote, “I have nothing new on the minority side since they are not doing anything about it. Unbelievable how De Jon’s name has not been mentioned as a candidate in Minnesota. He is definitely qualified for that position as GM for the Twins.”


“Two, three, four, five major things happened,” he said. “I think we counted on guys coming back from injuries and hoping they would be ok. Hughes and Perkins to name two,” he said, referring to pitchers Phil Hughes and Glen Perkins.