UNDER CONSTRUCTION IN PHILADELPHIA
Thursday, April 28th, 2016From 2007 through 2011, the Philadelphia Phillies won five division titles. It was the first time in the Phillies’ 129-year history that they finished in first place in five consecutive seasons. In that franchise-historic span, the team played in two successive World Series, winning one. In those five seasons, the Phillies won 89, 92, 93, 97 and 102 games.
In the four seasons since, they have dropped to third place in the National League East, then fourth and fifth and last each of the last two years, compiling records of 81-81, 73-89 twice and finally a major league-worst 63-99 last season.
When Andy MacPhail became the team’s president last Fall, it was obvious that his first move would be to replace Ruben Amaro Jr. as general manager. Amaro had been general manager for seven years, meaning he had overseen the Phillies’ descent into oblivion.
Amaro lived and died for the same reason. He inherited a World Series champion and didn’t do anything to update it and replace its aging parts. In some instances the Phillies hamstrung themselves with outrageously expensive contracts.
Ryan Howard, Chase Utley and Jimmy Rollins provide glaring examples of what the Phillies did to undermine their future. These contracts tell the sad tale:
- Howard: 5 years, $125 million April 2010 for 2012-16
- Utley: 7 years, $85 million January 2007 for 2007-13, $30 million extension for ‘14-’15, options for $15 million a year ’16-’18, becoming guaranteed based on number of plate appearances
- Rollins: 3 years, $33 million for 2012-’14, $11 million option for ’15, becoming guaranteed based on plate appearances
The new general manager opted to avoid making judgments on his predecessor’s decisions.
“I wasn’t here,” Matt Klentak said in a telephone interview last week. “I took the job in October. What I have observed since I’ve been here is questions people have raised, such as why didn’t they trade Rollins sooner.”
The Phillies traded Rollins to the Dodgers in December 2014. He was 36 years old. They traded Utley to the Dodgers last August. He was a few months short of turning 37. If the Phillies tried to trade Howard any time during the life of his contract, they would have found no takers at $25 million a year for a slugger who had become a shadow of his former self.
Klentak, however, stuck to his optimistic view.
“When I was going through the interview process,” he said, “it was apparent to me that this was an organization with a bright future.”
It would be easy to dismiss Klentak’s version of the Phillies’ future by considering the source – a newly hired general manager. Klentak, however, was not involved in drafting these players.
Baseball Prospectus is one of the most widely respected trackers of teams’ minor league systems. This is what the publication said of the Phillies’ system before the season:
“Long a laughingstock for prioritizing athletes who couldn’t hit, the Phillies are now as loaded at the top of the system as any team in baseball. The rebuild started later than it should have, but it might not take long.”
The names may not be familiar to most fans, but various websites that focus on minor league prospects list these players as the Phillies’ top prospects:
Pitchers Jake Thompson, Mark Appel, Franklyn Kilome, Andy Knapp and Ben Lively, shortstop J. P. Crawford, catcher Jorge Alfaro and outfielders Nick Williams, Cornelius Randolph and Roman Quinn.
As with any list of prospects, the Phillies have no guarantees with their prospects. Some undoubtedly will turn into suspects; some are likely to join the young players on the Phillies’ roster now and if the collection of players is good enough the Phillies could someday be contenders again.
The Royals and the pitching-rich Mets have done it. So have the Astros and the Pirates. The Cubs plan to do it this season and have begun the season as if they are serious about it.
Klentak is only 36, but he’s old enough to know how the Phillies grew into prominence in the previous decade.
“What made Phillies great on that run,” he said, “was they had exceptional success in drafting and developing players.
“The core of this team was built the right way,” he added. “That’s what we’re focused on now, building through the draft and international signings.”
Howard and catcher Carlos Ruiz are the only remaining starting position players from the World Series teams. Cesar Hernandez has replaced Utley at second base, Freddy Galvis is the shortstop in place of Rollins and Maikel Franco is the highly regarded third baseman in place of Pedro Feliz.
The World Series outfield had Jayson Werth in right, Shane Victorino in center and Pat Burrell (2008) and Ben Francisco and Raul Ibanez (2009) in left. This month’s outfield has been Peter Bourjos in right, Odubel Herrera in center and primarily Tyler Goeddel in left.
The Phillies are a long way from their next World Series, but at least they have improved in the early weeks of the season. They won 11 of their first 21 games (through Wednesday) compared with 8 wins in their first 21 games a year ago.
“I felt the direction of the club was positive,” said Klentak, who before taking the Philadelphia job had worked in Baltimore and Anaheim as assistant general manager. “We like the quality young players we have at the major league level, hopefully we have impact players at Double A and Triple A and we have the first pick in the draft.”
And if the listener still wasn’t convinced of Klentak’s position, he added, “I wouldn’t have left Mike Trout in his prime if I didn’t think the Phillies were a promising team.”