DEALING WITH DEAL DEADLINE
Monday, July 31st, 2017A year ago July 25 the Chicago Cubs acquired Aroldis Chapman from the New York Yankees. Six days later the Cleveland Indians obtained Andrew Miller from the Yankees. Left-handed relievers both, Chapman and Miller played significant roles in the 2016 World Series, justifying their teams’ decisions to trade for them.
Other teams, on the other hand, made pre-deadline deals that didn’t lead to post-season appearances. The teams making deals the past month aren’t guaranteed post-season spots either, but hopeful teams make this month perhaps the most intriguing of the season.
The deadline I refer to is July 31, the last day teams can trade players without having to obtain waivers on players they want to trade. Teams can trade players after July 31, but they have to have waivers on the players.
This July did not produce the trades of players as highly regarded as Chapman and Miller, but there have been some that could turn out to be significant.
Jose Quintana, for example, could pitch a three-hitter in the Cubs’ victory in Game 7 of the World Series, or J.D. Martinez could hit a game-winning home run for the Arizona Diamondbacks in the National League wild-card game. The Washington Nationals could ride the relief pitching of Ryan Madson and Sean Doolittle to the National League pennant. Could Todd Frazier regain his penchant for power hitting that he had in the previous three seasons and help power the Yankees to something more than a meaningless wild-card game? Jaime Garcia, acquired from Minnesota to replace the injured Michael Pineda in the Yankees’ starting rotation, could pitch more productively than Pineda.
The Yankees, though, know about July trades that don’t work out. In July 2014 General Manager Brian Cashman made five trades, acquiring pitchers Brandon McCarthy and Jeff Francis and infielders Chase Headley, Stephen Drew and Martin Prado.
At the time of the first of those five trades, the Yankees had a 43-43 record. They went 41-35 the rest of the season, an improvement but not enough to reach the post-season.
Headley, the only one of the five 2014 players still with the Yankees, currently as the first baseman, hit .229 in 58 games for the Yankees in 2014. Drew batted .150 in 46 games, Prado .316 in 37 games.
The month of July leading to the trade deadline has become a popular time of the baseball calendar for two reasons:
- Teams in post-season competition can find players to fill gaps in their rosters, in their starting lineups, in their pitching rotations and in their bullpens. The markets are often plentiful.
- Teams out of contention can take advantage of the market to trade off players with big contracts they no longer want to pay or players who are approaching free agency at the end of the season, and their teams would rather trade them and get something in return than lose them in two months or so and get nothing for them.
The timing, however, can create a quandary for teams caught in the middle. Are they buyers looking for players who can improve their status, or are they sellers seeking a club to take a big contract off their books or a pending free agent off their roster?
The Texas Rangers found themselves in that position the past month with Yu Darvish, their attractive starting pitcher.
The Rangers won negotiating rights to Darvish, a professional Japanese pitcher, and signed him in 2012 to a six-year, $56 million contract. This is the last year covered in the contract, and Darvish can be a free agent after the season.
The Rangers haven’t looked like a post-season contender, even for a wild-card spot. Before Monday’s game, they were fourth in the American League West, and four teams were ahead of them for the A.L.’s second wild card with three other teams tied with them. Their post-season chances don’t look too good.
Then there are the Oakland Athletics, whose head baseball man, Billy Beane, loves to trade pitchers before their time. Mark Mulder and Tim Hudson come immediately to mind. Somehow Barry Zito, who pitched with Mulder and Hudson, was retained until he was eligible for free agency. That season was 2006, and the A’s won the division title that year.
Oakland is not in position to win anything this season so Sonny Gray, the A’s 27-year-old right-hander, has been a subject of trade discussions for weeks even though he can’t be a free agent for two years. However, no one was going to be surprised if Beane traded him, though 12 hours before the trading deadline, Gray was still an Oakland pitcher.
Beane’s policy is simple. If a team wants to pay his price, he will make the trade. The price is high so interested teams will have to decide if the player is worth it. The player is usually a pitcher, and good pitchers are a highly desirable commodity.
Good pitchers have always been the most desirable commodity, and that’s why trades that have included pitchers have been the highlight of deadline trading. These July-acquired pitchers, starters and relievers, though, did not help their teams win:
Here are the notable pitching acquisitions by teams that ended up not making the post-season:
2016: Brad Ziegler and Drew Pomeranz (Red Sox), Drew Storen (Mariners), Mark Melanon (Nationals), Tyler Clippard (Yankees), Wade Miley (Orioles), Francisco Liriano and Scott Feldman (Blue Jays), Ivan Nova (Pirates), Matt Moore (Giants)
2015: Scott Kazmir (Astros), Tyler Clippard (Mets), Jonathan Papelbon (Nationals), Joakim Soria (Pirates), Mike Leake (Giants), Cole Hamels (Rangers), Ryan Cook (Red Sox), J.A. Happ (Pirates)
2014: Jason Hammel and Jeff Samardzija (Athletics), Brandon McCarthy and Jeff Francis (Yankees)
2013: Francisco Rodriguez (Orioles)
2012: Nathan Eovaldi (Marlins), Zack Greinke (Angels), Francisco Liriano (White Sox)
2011: Zack Wheeler (Mets), Ubaldo Jimenez (Indians)
2010: Dan Haren (Angels), Joe Saunders (Diamondbacks), Edwin Jackson (White Sox), Daniel Hudson (Diamondbacks), Jake Westbrook (Cardinals), Corey Kluber (Indians), Ted Lilly (Dodgers)
2009: Jake Peavy (White Sox), Clayton Richard (Padres)
2008: Kyle Farnsworth (Yankees)
2007: Octavio Dotel (Braves)
2006: Greg Maddux (Dodgers)