IS CASHMAN THE YANKEES’ VIRUS?
Sunday, September 30th, 2018I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again. The Yankees had no valid reason to fire Joe Girardi as their manager a year ago.
Let’s address this immediately. It is technically correct the Yankees did not fire Girardi – his contract expired at the end of the 2017 season and he was not offered a new contract. But when you’ve had a manager for 10 years and you don’t offer him a new contract when he wanted to return, that’s the same as firing him.
The Yankees, even Hal Steinbrenner, the managing general partner, have said they had legitimate reasons, something to do with what they claim was Girardi’s inability to connect with the young players.
I recall speaking to a club executive last year and questioning the decision to fire Girardi, and he said, “You weren’t in the clubhouse.”
No, I wasn’t, but I saw the results. Girardi’s wild-card Yankees went to the seventh and last game of the American League Championship Series before succumbing to the Houston Astros, who went on to win the World Series. Girardi managed the Yankees to the 2009 World Series championship and to three other post-season appearances.
Nevertheless, the Yankees treated him as badly as they did his predecessor, Joe Torre, when his contract expired, except unlike Torre, Girardi didn’t get a contract offer he could easily refuse.
Girardi received no offers to manage this year but did get an offer to serve as an analyst on the MLB Network. He recently declined to say if any team had contacted him about managing next season.
Two jobs have already opened – in Toronto and Texas – and more openings are expected, in Baltimore, Cincinnati and Anaheim, to name a few.
Although Girardi spent much of the season talking on television, he was not verbose on the telephone last week. I asked him about his dismissal by the Yankees, and he said, “I don’t mean to be evasive, but life goes on. I’ve moved on. It’s the nature of the business. Teams make changes.”
I asked him about his future, and he said, “I’m not comfortable doing this. I’d prefer not talking about it. I’m not comfortable.”
And on another subject, he said, “I won’t comment on that.”
However, when I asked him if he was finished managing or wanted to continue, he said, “I do want to manage again.”
But he declined to say if any teams have contacted him since the Yankees fired him.
Ten years and out the door. Girardi was 53 years old and certainly young enough to continue managing, but he was too old and had far too much managing experience to fit the plans of General Manager Brian Cashman.
In today’s changing baseball world, owners want younger general managers (with a degree in or knowledge of analytics) and general managers want younger and less experienced managers whom they can manipulate and control.
In the first year of his third decade as general manager of the Yankees, Cashman has more freedom than most other general managers. He has grown up in the organization and has been more involved in the baseball operations whereas Steinbrenner has been intimately involved only since his father took ill and died in 2010.
About six weeks after Girardi was excused from further employment with the Yankees, Steinbrenner told reporters Girardi would have been fired even if the Yankees had won the World Series.
What nonsense. I’m not sure that George Steinbrenner would have had the nerve to make such a move or such a claim. According to a club official, the decision was left to Cashman, and Cashman’s explanation for his decision was summed up in this website headline:
“Brian Cashman let Joe Girardi go over inability to connect with players”
So there we have it. It was a connectivity problem, like you have sometimes in trying to connect to the Internet.
I, however, have a believability problem. Am I supposed to believe that a manager who was a win away from going to the World Series had a communications problem with the team’s players, especially its young players?
Searching the Internet, I found no writer questioning Cashman’s connectivity explanation for his dismissal of Girardi. If the absence of question or doubt or challenge means the writers believe Cashman because they were aware of the problem, why didn’t anyone write it?
If it was true, why weren’t the writers aware of it? That sort of thing is an important reason why newspapers have reporters covering teams, that is, all newspapers except my former employer, The New York Times.
Let me take a closer look at the Cashman excuse for firing Girardi (by the way, you’ll notice that the Yankees under Aaron Boone, a nice fellow from a good family, are no better off than they were a year ago at this time under Girardi).
Aaron Judge played 155 games, starting 151, hit 52 home runs, drove in 114 runs, scored 128, was named American League Rookie of the Year and was second in the A.L. MVP voting, etc., etc., etc. Was Judge one of the young players who had a connectivity problem with Girardi?
Gary Sanchez , a rookie catcher, hit 33 home runs and drove in 90 runs, winning a Silver Slugger award as the league’s best hitting catcher.
Luis Severino, a 24-year-old won 14 games and lost 6, compiling a 2.96 earned run average in his first full major league season.
If a more communications-connected manager had been managing the Yankees, would Judge have hit 62 home runs, would Sanchez have driven in 100 runs, would Severino have won 20 games, would the Yankees have won Game 7 of the A.L.C.S. and then beaten the Los Angeles Dodgers in the World Series?
Should Cashman have known sooner that he had a connectivity problem in the clubhouse and that Girardi was a dangerous element, a bat in the belfry? Why did it take Cashman six weeks of spring training and six months of the season to figure out he had a connectivity problem in the clubhouse?
I mean it often takes me an unusually long time to figure out that I have a connectivity problem with my computer, and when I do, I call my son. But I’m not a professional computer guy. Cashman is a professional baseball man. If his system becomes infested with a virus, he should be able to spot it quickly and eliminate it promptly.
Blame the Yankees’ failure last year on Cashman, not Girardi. Maybe young Mr. Steinbrenner, you should think about that virus and if you determine that it’s Cashman, spray him quickly with pesticide and wipe out the real virus. You may then want to invite Girardi to a meeting and figure out a way to make amends. Good luck in your quest to locate and eliminate that pesky virus.